1 "Flowers single or in cymes in axils of leaf-like bracts along parts of or all branches; annuals" 2 1 "Flowers in terminal rounded inflorescences with reduced bracts; perennials with leaves usually longer than 12 mm" 14 2 "Flowers in the axil of one leaf at each node; calyx half to two-thirds as long as the corolla" 3 2 "Flowers in the axil of both leaves at a node; calyx at least as long as corolla" 4 3 "Carpels each with 1 ovule" "Crassula natans var. minor" 3 "Carpels each with 2–14 ovules" "Crassula peduncularis" 4 "Inflorescence a flat-topped terminal thyrsoid" "Crassula glomerata" 4 "Inflorescence elongate, terminal or axillary" 5 5 "Flowers pedicellate and loosely arranged along usually much-branched branches" 6 5 "Flowers sessile or almost so in spike-like inflorescences; plants little-branched mainly from the base" 10 6 "Carpels each with 4–24 ovules" 7 6 "Carpels each with 2 ovules" 8 7 "Seeds less than twice as long as broad, with widely spaced papillae along the vertical ridges; branches erect; calyx-lobes and bracts papillate toward the apex" "Crassula closiana" 7 "Seeds greater than twice as long as broad, with dense papillae (c. touching one another) along vertical ridges; branches often decumbent; calyx-lobes usually smooth" "Crassula decumbens var. decumbens" 8 "Flowers 5-merous; much-branched, decumbent annual" "Crassula thunbergiana subsp. thunbergiana" 8 "Flowers 4-merous; erect or decumbent annuals, or decumbent perennials" 9 9 "Decumbent annuals, branched from base; fruiting calyx 0.5–1(–1.1) mm long, lobes spreading, somewhat fleshy, rarely with membranous margins" "Crassula tetramera" 9 "Erect annuals or decumbent perennials; fruiting calyx (1.1–)1.2–2.2 mm long, apex of lobes clasping each other or erect and lobes flattened to a more or less membranous margin" "Crassula colligata subsp. lamprosperma" 10 "Flowers mainly 3-merous" "Crassula alata var. alata" 10 "Flowers 4- or 5-merous" 11 11 "Follicles often tuberculate, not splitting longitudinally, detaching basally to release seed; styles at least two-thirds as long as bodies of carpels" "Crassula colorata" 11 "Follicles smooth or papillose, splitting longitudinally from apex on adaxial side, but often detaching basally to release seed; styles up to one-quarter as long as bodies of carpels" 12 12 "Fruiting calyx-lobes incurved between half exposed recurved follicles" "Crassula exserta" 12 "Fruiting calyx-lobes erect, enclosing erect follicles" 13 13 "Decumbent annuals, branched from base; fruiting calyx 0.5–1(–1.1) mm long, lobes spreading, somewhat fleshy, rarely with membranous margins" "Crassula tetramera" 13 "Erect annuals or decumbent perennials; fruiting calyx (1.1–)1.2–2.2 mm long, apex of lobes clasping each other or erect and lobes flattened to a more or less membranous margin" "Crassula colligata subsp. lamprosperma" 14 "Leaves petiolate, rarely sessile, loosely opposite; corolla star-shaped" "Crassula multicava" 14 "Leaves sessile, stiffly 4-ranked or opposite; corolla tubular" "Crassula tetragona subsp. robusta"