1 "Annual; leaf < 1 cm; flower 1--5 mm" 2 1 "Generally perennial herb to shrub; leaf > 1 cm; flower generally > 10 mm (if annual, flower > 4 mm)" 3 2 "Basal, cauline leaves opposite, bases fused, +- sheathing; flowers 1 in axils of leaves; petals < 2 mm" Crassula 2 "Basal leaves opposite, cauline alternate, bases free, not sheathing; flowers 1 or >= 2 in cyme, terminal; petals 1.3--5 mm" Sedella 3 "Subshrub to shrub" 4 3 "Perennial herb (annual or biennial in Sedum radiatum)" 7 4 "Leaves alternate" 5 4 "Leaves opposite" 6 5 "Leaves ciliate, rosettes terminal; sepals 7--11" Aeonium 5 "Leaves not ciliate, rosettes 0; sepals 5" Sedum 6 "Leaves generally 2--4 pairs; petals fused, tube >> sepals" "Cotyledon {Cotyledon orbiculata var. oblonga}" 6 "Leaves generally > 4 pairs; petals free or +- fused at base, tube 0" Crassula 7 "Inflorescences axillary" Dudleya 7 "Inflorescences terminal" 8 8 "Sepals, petals generally 5" Sedum 8 "Sepals, petals generally 4" 9 9 "Flowers bisexual; stamens = sepals in number" Crassula 9 "Flowers +- unisexual; stamens 2 × sepals in number" "Rhodiola {Rhodiola integrifolia subsp. integrifolia}"