1 "Heads +- sessile, sometimes in dense 2° clusters" 2 1 "Heads peduncled" 5 2 "Heads 1-flowered, in dense 2° heads; plant +- spiny" 3 2 "Heads 3--20-flowered, solitary or clustered; plant not spiny" 4 3 "Herb, 10--20 dm, stout, erect; leaves large, 1--2-pinnately lobed, spiny-margined; 2° heads spheric" "Echinops {Echinops sphaerocephalus}" 3 "Shrub, 4--7 dm; leaves small, spine-tipped, margins weakly spiny; 2° heads not spheric, +- concealed by veiny bracts" "Hecastocleis {Hecastocleis shockleyi}" 4 "Leaf tips generally 3-lobed; pappus not falling in a ring" Eriophyllum 4 "Leaf tips entire; pappus falling in a ring" "Orochaenactis {Orochaenactis thysanocarpha}" 5 "Phyllaries unequal, graduated in 2--many series, outer << inner" 6 5 "Phyllaries or phyllary-like paleae +- equal (or outer > inner), in 1--3 series" 10 6 "Pappus of short scales alternating with longer awns or bristles" 7 6 "Pappus of readily deciduous awns or narrow, bristle-like scales, or of scales that are +- dissected into bristles" 8 7 "Annual; leaves linear, generally entire" "Malperia {Malperia tenuis}" 7 "Perennial herb or subshrub; leaves lanceolate to +- diamond-shaped, generally few-toothed" "Pleurocoronis {Pleurocoronis pluriseta}" 8 "Shrub; phyllary tips appressed" "Acamptopappus sphaerocephalus" 8 "Herb; phyllary tips often spreading to recurved" 9 9 "Involucre gummy; pappus awns readily deciduous" Grindelia 9 "Involucre hairy or glandular; pappus scales often +- dissected into bristles" Lessingia 10 "Head +- spheric; leaves decurrent" Helenium 10 "Head cylindric to hemispheric; leaves not decurrent" 11 11 "Phyllary margins +- scarious, white to yellow, red, or purple" 12 11 "Phyllary or phyllary-like palea margins not evidently scarious, generally +- green" 14 12 "Pappus scales bristle-tipped; corollas cream to white or purple-tinged" Hymenothrix 12 "Pappus scales obtuse to acute; corollas generally yellow" 13 13 "Annual; pappus scales generally 8" "Bahia {Bahia neomexicana}" 13 "Perennial herb; pappus scales 12--22" Hymenopappus 14 "Corollas white to purple" 15 14 "Corollas yellow" 16 15 "Fruit 3--9 mm; pappus scale midrib 0; leaves often toothed or lobed" Chaenactis 15 "Fruit 10--15 mm; pappus scale midrib well developed; leaves entire" Palafoxia 16 "Outer corollas +- bilateral, much enlarged, ray-like; pappus scales entire or toothed" "Chaenactis glabriuscula" 16 "Outer corollas generally radial, not or only slightly enlarged; pappus scales plumose or dissected into bristles" 17 17 "Annual or short-lived perennial herb; rhizome 0" 18 17 "Perennial herb with rhizome" 19 18 "Leaf teeth and lobes blunt; involucre densely glandular; pappus scales plumose" "Layia discoidea" 18 "Leaf teeth and lobes sharp; involucre not glandular; pappus scales dissected into bristles" "Trichoptilium {Trichoptilium incisum}" 19 "Leaves mostly or all basal" Raillardella 19 "Leaves basal and cauline, well distributed on stem" 20 20 "Glandless hairs restricted to margins of phyllary-like paleae" "Anisocarpus scabridus" 20 "Glandless hairs not restricted to margins of phyllary-like paleae" "Carlquistia {Carlquistia muirii}"