1 "Ovules attached to central column of the ovary (ovule placentation axile) " 2 1 "Ovules attached to outer wall of ovary or appearing to be attached at the base of the ovary (placentation parietal) " 3 2 "Plant annual or biennial" Mesembryanthemum 2 "Plant perennial " Aptenia 3 "Fruit fleshy, not splitting open at maturity (indehiscent) " Carpobrotus 3 "Fruit splitting open at maturity (a dry capsule) " 4 4 "Plant annual " Dorotheanthus 4 "Plants perennial " 5 5 "Plants with the leaves separated so that the stem nodes are clearly visible between the leaf pairs " 6 5 "Plants with the leaf pairs close together so that the nodes are not visible " 10 6 "Stigmas broadly triangular or ovate " 7 6 "Stigmas narrow and pointed, linear or threadlike " 9 7 "Plants without small blunt surface protuberances (papillae) " Lampranthus 7 "Plants with papillae " 8 8 "Papillae forming small shiny globules on the leaf surface " Drosanthemum 8 "Papillae not glistening " Delosperma 9 "Leaves 3-angled, grey-blue with the margins often toothed; nectary glands 5, discrete " Oscularia 9 "Leaves mostly green, generally with a lower toothed ridge; nectary glands in scalloped ring " Ruschia 10 "Plants with a solitary pair of leaves on the flowering shoot " 11 10 "Plants with more than one pair of leaves on the flowering shoots " 13 11 "Leaves united for less than half their length and not forming a body, surface with distinctive dark green dots " Pleiospilos 11 "Leaves united for at least half of their lengths to form a plant body " 12 12 "Sepals united into a tube at the base; leaves rarely coloured, wrinkled or windowed " Conophytum 12 "Sepals free; plant body of 2 pebble-like leaves, often coloured, wrinkled or with a translucent window " Lithops 13 "Leaves spoon-shaped, flattened " Aloinopsis 13 "Leaves not as above " 14 14 "Leaf surface with conspicuous dark green dots " Pleiospilos 14 "Leaf surface without conspicuous dark green dots " 15 15 "Leaves finger-like, roundish in section with translucent ‘windows’ at the tips " Fenestraria 15 "Leaves not as above " 16 16 "Leaves with a cup-like dry, papery sheath " Cheiridopsis 16 "Leaves not as above " 17 17 "Leaf pairs clearly different " Glottiphyllum 17 "Leaf pairs similar, jaw-like, with backwardly pointed teeth on the margins " Faucaria