1 "Stigma lobes white to yellow " 2 1 "Stigma lobes orange, pink, red or purple " 8 2 "Body extremely small, mostly much less than 4 cm wide and without ribs, tubercles or spines " "Parodia liliputana" 2 "Body not as above " 3 3 "Ribs vertical, distinct; flowers more than 4.5 cm wide " 4 3 "Ribs spiralling, indestinct or formed of tubercles; flowers often more than 4.5 cm wide " 6 4 "Ribs 11–16 " "Parodia magnifica" 4 "Ribs more than 20 " 5 5 "Spines 6–11 per areole " "Parodia schumanniana" 5 "Spines more than 18 " "Parodia leninghausii" 6 "Pericarpel with dense white or brown wool largely concealing the few bristles; (bristles on most scales of flower tube, ribs spiral, flowers mostly yellow) " "Parodia chrysacanthion" 6 "Pericarpel, tube and fruit with bristles and wool " 7 7 "Flowers red, stamens concealed by perianth " "Parodia haselbergii" 7 "Flowers yellowish, stamens apparent " "Parodia graessneri" 8 "Ribs shallow and rounded; flowers of 1 colour " 9 8 "Ribs more than 5 mm tall with sharp ridge; flowers; of 1 or 2 colours " 10 9 "Stems slightly flattened spines mostly less than 15 per areole; flowers purple, white or yellow " "Parodia crassigibba" 9 "Stems spherical or cylindrical; spines about 20–40; flowers bright yellow " "Parodia scopa" 10 "Flowers magenta with pale or yellow throat (ribs less than 5 mm deep) " "Parodia rutilans" 10 "Flowers of 1 colour " 11 11 "Spines flexible, flowers pale orange " "Parodia horstii" 11 "Spines rigid " 12 12 "Body dark green; spines at least 8 per areole, ribs mostly 15–25 " "Parodia mammulosa" 12 "Body mostly grey-green to waxy blue; spines to 8 per areole, ribs " "Parodia buiningii"