1 "Leaves opposite, more or less fused at the base, usually with hydathodes along the margin; stamens in 1 whorl; flowers (3–)5(–9)-parted" Crassula 1 "Leaves alternate, opposite or whorled, free (sometimes slightly basally fused in Kalanchoe), with a single apical hydathode; stamens in 2 whorls, double the number of petals, outer whorl opposite the petals (if 1-whorled, leaves never opposite); flowers (4–)5(–16)-parted" 2 2 "Flowers 4-parted; petals fused forming a tube" 3 2 "Flowers 5(–16)-parted (if ever 4-parted as in some Sedum species then petals free); petals usually free, or basally united, or forming a tube" 4 3 "Flowers pendulous; corolla usually broadly cylindrical to urn-shaped; filaments fused to the corolla tube in the lower third" Bryophyllum 3 "Flowers erect and spreading; corolla tube narrowly cylindrical; filaments fused to the corolla tube at or above the middle" Kalanchoe 4 "Inflorescence terminal" 5 4 "Inflorescence lateral" 11 5 "Flowers 6–16-parted; leaves usually in rosettes; leaf margins ciliate or pubescent" 6 5 "Flowers 5-parted (if ever 6–7-parted as in some Sedum species then leaves not in rosettes); leaves often distributed evenly along stem/branch length, occasionally in rosettes; leaf margins not ciliate or pubescent (or rarely in some Sedum species and then leaves not in rosettes or hairs distributed all over leaf surface)" 8 6 "Stem-forming plants, occasionally rosettes more or less stalkless (as in A. tabuliforme and A. canariense), flowers (6–)7–9(–16)-parted" Aeonium 6 "Leaf rosettes stemless, leaves tufted; flowers 6–16-parted" 7 7 "Petals entire, star-shaped, spreading, flowers (8–)10–14(–16)-parted" Sempervivum 7 "Petals more or less fimbriate, erect (flower bell-shaped), 6–7-parted" Jovibarba 8 "Petals free or rarely basally fused, radially spreading; corolla not forming a tube (or very rarely)" Sedum 8 "Petals fused; corolla forming a tube" 9 9 "Leaves opposite; flowers pendulous; sepals hairless; nectary cup-shaped" Cotyledon 9 "Leaves alternate; flowers erect or spreading (pendulous in Adromischus phillipsiae); sepals with (or often with) club-shaped hairs; nectary disc-like" 10 10 "Leaves deciduous, inflorescence stalk with a gradual transition from leaves to bracts; petals fused for less than the full length of the tube" Tylecodon 10 "Leaves alternate; inflorescence stalk with an abrupt transition from leaves to bracts; petals fused beyond the tube" Adromischus 11 "Petals spreading radially from midway" 12 11 "Petals erect or only slightly spreading at apices" 16 12 "Petals with a pair of scale-like appendages at the base of stamens" ×Pachyveria 12 "Petals without a pair of scale-like appendages" 13 13 "Petals distinctly red- or brown-spotted" Graptopetalum 13 "Petals not spotted" 14 14 "Petals free" "Sedum suaveolens" 14 "Petals basally fused" 15 15 "Sepals reflexed" Tacitus 15 "Sepals erect or adpressed" Dudleya 16 "Petals with a pair of scale-like appendages at the base of stamens" Pachyphytum 16 "Petals without a pair of scale-like appendages" 17 17 "Leaves awn-tipped or inflorescence with large leafy bracts, or petals spotted" ×Graptoveria 17 "Leaves not awn-tipped, inflorescence with small scattered bracts only, and petals not spotted" 18 18 "Corolla not rolled up in bud, usually strongly pentagonal; petals thick and fleshy, sharply keeled; sepals more or less spreading; leaves narrow-based, not readily detachable" Echeveria 18 "Corolla rolled up in bud, slightly angled only; petals thin, scarcely keeled; sepals erect or adpressed; leaves broad-based, not readily detachable" Dudleya